Displayed prices are for multiple nights. Check the site for price per night. I see hostels starting at 200b/day and hotels from 500b/day on agoda.
-
Posts
3,859 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
85
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by Bruce Mangosteen
-
My calculator says it's 200 BILLION baht. My friend google says that just Bangkok Bank has about 4.7 trillion in assets. Also, your assumption is that every expat has banked 800k. See my thread for that discussion, but I'd be surprised if the number was as much as half that. While the street-level economy would of course miss our spending, the PTB DGAF IMO. To them we're a bunch of filthy whoremongers who are befouling their women and bringing degenerate ideas into their sacred country. There are many internet sources that talk about this, especially the portrayal of foreigners in Thai popular culture. However, coincidentally, a website also discussed on this site recently posted a short vignette discussing it. https://pattayaunfiltered.com/2026/11/13/the-ghost-in-the-classroom-why-the-smile-stops-at-the-eyes/ We're barbarian invaders to the Thai elite. They'd happily give us back every penny if it meant seeing the last of us go home. Again, this is the elite I'm talking about. Most average Thais have a neutral-to-positive attitude toward us in my experience. However, it's the elite who make the rules. Hence the disconnect we all feel, including in your post, but few understand, and even fewer keep in mind.
- 1 reply
-
- 1
-
-
Certainly the risk/ reward calculation is every individual's to choose for himself. However, I personally know someone who had money disappear from his account, and there have been news reports on it happening, including to Thais (thought I posted a link to one). It's also very well known that there have been several waves of farang bank accounts summarily locked and closed. So it HAS gotten around, but it's not like you can avoid the Thai banking system if you want a visa. OTOH, the agents are still going strong, and if anything there are many more of them now than there ever were. I have to believe that the (corrupt) monetary value they generate alone would make that hard to change. Swings and roundabouts mate. Ya pays ya money, and takes ya chances. Good luck with whatever you decide.
-
From agents? I doubt it mate. That news would flash though expat circles like a nuclear explosion. If anything, given how hard they're making it for individual foreigners to open a bank account and provide the correct financial documentation, it almost seems like they're pushing for everyone to use agents. A poster on another board recently reported that he switched from doing his own yearly renewal to using an agent because of this. And lose all their customers when it got around? Seems a bad cost/benefit calculation to me. Also, how might they do that without incriminating themselves? Wouldn't they also expose the Immigration Agent they were paying to possible problems? Isn't this a bit like a drug dealer threatening to turn a customer in to the cops? I don't think this is how corruption works. Everyone involved has to have skin in the game for corruption to work correctly and be sustainable (to use a fancy modern buzzword). All that said, everybody makes this call for themselves. The only truly wrong answer IMO is when it goes tits up, either because of official crackdowns, or due to the banks deciding they DGAF if your money disappears from your account, or it gets frozen or closed.
-
I don't think Thai Immigration cares which bank you use. Some time back BB engaged in a much-ballyhooed tightening in their documentation requirements, and froze some foreigners' accounts that didn't meet their new standards. Here is the current state of play: https://huahinvisa.net/open-bank-account-bangkok-bank/ If you're in a properly-registered marriage your wife should be able to provide you a reference, but it's not clear to me if you must already have the retirement extension in order to open the account, rather than just the non-O visa. I'd suggest asking the branch where you plan to open the account, as they appear to have some discretion in what documentation they can require.
-
This does not match my memory of my previous time holding the retirement extension, nor does it match what I thought the agent at Maneerat told me. My understanding based on those two factors is that it's a simple 90 day report, although the first one is required to be done in person (if you don't use an agent) rather than using the online service. This web page seems to confirm that: https://www.immigration.go.th/en?page_id=1666 ("The first application for extension of stay by the foreigner is equivalent to the notification of staying in the Kingdom over 90 days", that being the application for the retirement extension itself) although I'll confirm it with Maneerat within the 15 day window. I plan to let them do the first 15 day report. Edit: Based on rereading the rest of your post, I think you meant the yearly renewal of the retirement extension, rather than the first 90 day report? In that case, it would confirm my suspicion that doing the transfers ain't worth the hassle, especially for the first renewal. This is what I figure I'll do if I subsequently decide to bite the bullet and transfer the 800K. Ultimate simplicity, no risk of falling below the minimum requirement.
-
I've been giving the topic of monthly transfers some thought. While I'm sure there are people out there who have done it, I've never personally met or talked to anyone who has successfully renewed a retirement extension based on monthly transfers. It's always the 800K route, real or not. My gut feeling is that's because the Thais purposely make it difficult to document the transfers to their satisfaction, preferring to simply see the 800K in the bank. And, there's certainly good logic behind that: 800K baht is roughly a year's worth of 65K transfers, plus a little left over to buy a plane ticket home. I've already explained my maladjustments with leaving 800K in a bank here. My maladjustments with the monthly transfer thing are: It forces me to structure my transfers in a way I think I will find inconvenient to handle and track, If I somehow feck one transfer up, all the effort to do and document the transfers in a particular way is wasted, and The Thais could just reject it for no good reason, regardless of how scrupulous I am with documenting it. The visa is structured such that I have a couple of months to think about this before the 1 year period starts. However, I'm leaning toward just paying Maneerat for the phantom 800K, and washing my hands of the entire question. Thoughts, anyone?
-
A response was posted to this on another board I post on which I will paraphrase here: It's possible to do Wise transfers if they are clearly marked as originating outside Thailand. This only seems to work for Bangkok Bank and Kasikorn. The process varies by bank. More info here: https://wise.com/help/articles/2932335/guide-to-thb-transfers Again, I didn't post this and can't vouch for it.
-
I asked the staff at Maneerat, and they told me that the transfers had to be bank to bank, especially not a service like Wise, and that I should provide documentation on both the sending account and the receiving account. I'll see if I can get any other confirmation of that. If anyone thinks differently, please post it on here, especially including any documentation to support it.
-
Got it back yesterday. Beers were consumed at TQ after to celebrate.
-
Got a text today at 4:15 saying that I could pick up my passport any day. Before 4:00.
-
Anyone here gone through the O-1 visa?
Bruce Mangosteen replied to AlexGreenePT's topic in Expat Issues
They why would you be remotely interested in a US visa? -
Surrender accepted, hilloshitsme. Irrelevant quoted post ignored. As I said to awesum4, I had planned to use a service after I got here, right from the beginning. That decision should have been clear from the get-go based on a previous post I made on this thread: That post clearly shows that a) I had planned on using a service from the beginning, and b) I know the correct procedure to get the visa without a service. That plan and decision was based on my several decades of visiting, working, owning and running businesses, and living here, having held a variety of visas during that time; and factoring in the fact that the visa situation was going to be more difficult here than usual due to recent changes in government policy, and my unshakeable distrust of the Thai banking system. That is, I used my decades of experience as an actual Thailand "seasoned veteran", made up my own mind about the best way forward in my situation, and achieved the exact result I wanted. I do not dispute the fact that there were other possible ways to get the visa, and I do not dispute that they are cheaper. I simply decided not to get the visa that way. Based on my decades of experience and direct knowledge of Thailand, I decided that parking ~$25K of my hard-earned retirement money in a Thai bank account was a risk that I was not prepared to take, so the official way of getting the visa for me was a non-starter. The work-around I tried failed, but it cost me exactly $0, and it was an interesting experience with Thai immigration that I learned from. Therefore the only real decision I had left to make was which visa service to use. My money, my choice. It's really just that simple. [/exchange] And, to repeat: I harbor no ill will toward you or anyone else on here. If I run into you somewhere, first drink's on me. Cheers. [/exchange]
-
Not if the 800K disappears from my account with no explanation, as happens occasionally, including to Thais. And yes, I do personally know someone it happened to.
-
To be quite honest, and notwithstanding some of the commentary on this thread, I had always figured on using a service when I got here. This was partially because I underestimated the increase in cost of the corruption involved, and partially because I don't want to tie up $25,000 or so in a Thai bank, preferring to leave it where it will earn a better return and be safe from the waves of bank account closures and freezes that sweep through the country occasionally. I got the exact outcome I wanted: A non-O, retirement extension, and a bank account, and $23,500 of my retirement money still safely in the US. My next step will be to ascertain what it will take to document monthly transfers in a way that will be acceptable to Thai immigration. I will document that on here.
-
Anyway, this seems as good of a place as any to state clearly that I harbor no ill will toward anyone on this board regardless of the tenor of past exchanges (specifically including teelak and hiiloshitsme), and would have no issue drinking in company with anyone on here. The board is the board, real life is real.
-
The immigration officer mostly focused on the income verification during the interview. Without the bank account, the only thing she said she could accept was a letter from the embassy. The US Embassy stopped that in 2019 because they refused to comply with the Thai requirement for a statement vouching for the specific income amount. Before the interview, we specifically asked the information desk outside if the documentation I brought was sufficient (a form letter from the Social Security Administration documenting my monthly payment, and a screenshot of the deposits from the account they are deposited in), and they said it was. The form to use to convert an airport stamp to a non-O is TM.87. I had one of those and she wasn't bothered to look at it, likely because of the above. Pretty funny, eh hilloshitsme? BTW, p'raps you could point me to all this advice I supposedly got from "seasoned veterans" (most of whom have been coming here for half the time I have, and whose entire Thailand experience consists of paying for blowjobs and getting treated for STDs), as well as you? Reading board posts from random alcoholics and whoremongers about Thai immigration isn't particularly persuasive I'm afraid.
-
Maneerat got the job. At 50,500 baht they were about 10K under my next best offer. Bank account, non-O visa, retirement extension, multiple reentry permit.
-
Went down in a massive tower of flames! LOL! Oh well, worth the try. Now researching visa services. Maneerat on Soi Post Office best so far.
-
Ha, the clamor of the crowd has reached our ears! 😆 The condo was repaired and we moved in the 21st of last month. Life has been a blur since. Family visiting, prepped for and attended the wife's daughter's wedding in Kanchanaburi where I was honored to stand "father of the bride" and give the bride away, back to Ayutthaya for a few days featuring a couple of drunken nights at Cowboy Bar and a photo session in Thai formal garb at a couple of old temples, then 4 grandchildren accompanied us back to Pattaya. They went home yesterday, groaning under stacks of new books and pastel pencils. Wife and I are now decompressing from all that with some well-deserved downtime. Just set up my computer for the first time since I got here. Managed to keep my world turning until now with my S24Ultra and its "Dex" desktop feature and a portable monitor, but some things still need Windows unfortunately. Next hurdle will be the visa. Working with a Thai friend who has some experience with this to try to avoid the extortionate prices the services now charge due to the present visa situation. Might have found a work-around, which I'll post if it works. Otherwise, I might have to leave Thailand for a spell and apply for an O visa. Negotiating with a customer for some remote work. Might have sold him a monthly "subscription" for a few hours' work at a reasonable rate. He's on holiday I think so waiting for him to break his radio silence. To be continued...
-
OK, sorry for the radio silence. Been here for a couple of weeks, not spent much time on the internet. It looks like we have found a place. It's actually two adjacent studio apartments on a low floor in VT2 with a locking door between, owned by a friend. The plan is to modify one of the rooms into an office/TV room with a folding bed for visiting grandchildren. 15K/month complete, rent to buy option under discussion, which I thought was a good price. It's currently unoccupied so needs some cleaning up, and there's also a problem with one of the bathrooms he's working on getting fixed. We're hoping to be in there around or before October 1. Fingers crossed. I'll update this thread occasionally. Thanks to all for your suggestions. See yas around town! 😃
-
help to choose hotel in Pattaya
Bruce Mangosteen replied to Kev's topic in General Discussion about Pattaya
After my several posts earlier, I decided to book the Holiday Inn Express on Soi Buakhao. Lo and behold, they're running a special, 1077++/night. Solid savings over the LK, similar quality hotel. -
help to choose hotel in Pattaya
Bruce Mangosteen replied to Kev's topic in General Discussion about Pattaya
Huh, didn't know that. https://www.agoda.com/about-agoda/weve-been-doing-what-we-do-since-2005/ The Agoda company was acquired by Booking Holdings [NASDAQ: BKNG] (previously The Priceline Group) back in 2007. We share the same parent company as other familiar names such as Booking.com, Priceline.com, Kayak.com, and Opentable.com. I haven't booked many rooms since I came back to the US to work ~7 years ago, so my experience with this sort of stuff is admittedly sparse and stale at this point. That will soon change... 😎 -
help to choose hotel in Pattaya
Bruce Mangosteen replied to Kev's topic in General Discussion about Pattaya
I remember reading somewhere that they don't just list available rooms and take a commission, they buy bulk blocks of rooms in advance and negotiate very low rates that way. Not sure if/which other booking services do this, but at least in my experience Agoda's prices are at the low end when comparing to other booking sites, and this might help explain it.
