Jump to content
Instructions on joining the Members Only Forum

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
On 11/1/2026 at 3:34 PM, Bruce Mangosteen said:

My next step will be to ascertain what it will take to document monthly transfers in a way that will be acceptable to Thai immigration.  I will document that on here.

I asked the staff at Maneerat, and they told me that the transfers had to be bank to bank, especially not a service like Wise, and that I should provide documentation on both the sending account and the receiving account.  I'll see if I can get any other confirmation of that.  If anyone thinks differently, please post it on here, especially including any documentation to support it.

Edited by Bruce Mangosteen
  • Like 1
Posted

A response was posted to this on another board I post on which I will paraphrase here:

It's possible to do Wise transfers if they are clearly marked as originating outside Thailand.  This only seems to work for Bangkok Bank and Kasikorn.  The process varies by bank.

More info here: https://wise.com/help/articles/2932335/guide-to-thb-transfers

Again, I didn't post this and can't vouch for it.

Posted

I've been giving the topic of monthly transfers some thought.

While I'm sure there are people out there who have done it, I've never personally met or talked to anyone who has successfully renewed a retirement extension based on monthly transfers. It's always the 800K route, real or not. My gut feeling is that's because the Thais purposely make it difficult to document the transfers to their satisfaction, preferring to simply see the 800K in the bank.

And, there's certainly good logic behind that: 800K baht is roughly a year's worth of 65K transfers, plus a little left over to buy a plane ticket home.

I've already explained my maladjustments with leaving 800K in a bank here. My maladjustments with the monthly transfer thing are:

  • It forces me to structure my transfers in a way I think I will find inconvenient to handle and track,

  • If I somehow feck one transfer up, all the effort to do and document the transfers in a particular way is wasted, and

  • The Thais could just reject it for no good reason, regardless of how scrupulous I am with documenting it.

The visa is structured such that I have a couple of months to think about this before the 1 year period starts. However, I'm leaning toward just paying Maneerat for the phantom 800K, and washing my hands of the entire question.

Thoughts, anyone?

  • Like 1
Posted

My plan is to have the Thai wife put her money (800,000 baht) already in her Kasikorn account into my account for the required time each year. This way I'll leave my money in Australia in a pension account and get a monthly payment. I'll then transfer whatever amount I need for the month over to my Kasikorn account using Wise.

If this doesn't work out or the missus gives all her money away to the family then I'll transfer over 800,000 baht into my Kasikorn account and not touch it. I should try to open an account with another bank as well. This will hopefully allow me to have a spending account so the 800,000 stays safe in another account.

  • Upvote 1
Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, InCider said:

I think the main stumbling block is for the FIRST extension on a 90-day non-immigrant type O Visa. This has to be done with banked money (or use an agent).

This does not match my memory of my previous time holding the retirement extension, nor does it match what I thought the agent at Maneerat told me.  My understanding based on those two factors is that it's a simple 90 day report, although the first one is required to be done in person (if you don't use an agent) rather than using the online service.  This web page seems to confirm that:  https://www.immigration.go.th/en?page_id=1666 ("The first application for extension of stay by the foreigner is equivalent to the notification of staying in the Kingdom over 90 days", that being the application for the retirement extension itself) although I'll confirm it with Maneerat within the 15 day window.  I plan to let them do the first 15 day report.

Edit:  Based on rereading the rest of your post, I think you meant the yearly renewal of the retirement extension, rather than the first 90 day report?  In that case, it would confirm my suspicion that doing the transfers ain't worth the hassle, especially for the first renewal.

6 hours ago, thegrogmonster said:

If this doesn't work out or the missus gives all her money away to the family then I'll transfer over 800,000 baht into my Kasikorn account and not touch it. I should try to open an account with another bank as well. This will hopefully allow me to have a spending account so the 800,000 stays safe in another account.

This is what I figure I'll do if I subsequently decide to bite the bullet and transfer the 800K.  Ultimate simplicity, no risk of falling below the minimum requirement.

Edited by Bruce Mangosteen
  • Like 1
Posted

I am planning to put 800,000 in an account and leave it there, it is simple and the interest on a term deposit here wouldn't be huge, especially if you deduct the extra fee you are paying an agent each year.

I presumed I could open 2 accounts at the same bank, one for everyday use and the one holding the 800,000.  Is this not possible?

Can I use Bangkok Bank ( my partners bank) or does the 800,000 have to be in Kasikorn.

Posted
On 11/7/2026 at 4:43 PM, awesum4 said:

Can I use Bangkok Bank ( my partners bank) or does the 800,000 have to be in Kasikorn.

I don't think Thai Immigration cares which bank you use. 

Some time back BB engaged in a much-ballyhooed tightening in their documentation requirements, and froze some foreigners' accounts that didn't meet their new standards.  

Here is the current state of play:  https://huahinvisa.net/open-bank-account-bangkok-bank/ 

If you're in a properly-registered marriage your wife should be able to provide you a reference, but it's not clear to me if you must already have the retirement extension in order to open the account, rather than just the non-O visa.  I'd suggest asking the branch where you plan to open the account, as they appear to have some discretion in what documentation they can require.

Posted

not in a properly-registered marriage.

having trouble applying for the 90 day retirement visa... but i am pretty sure its an issue between my bank and Kasikorn, hopefully it will be resolved tomorrow. otherwise I have plans B, C and D worked out, if they all fail i will go with plan E which is what you did but with an agent in Hua Hin. 

Posted (edited)
On 11/7/2026 at 10:03 AM, Bruce Mangosteen said:

This does not match my memory of my previous time holding the retirement extension, nor does it match what I thought the agent at Maneerat told me.  My understanding based on those two factors is that it's a simple 90 day report, although the first one is required to be done in person (if you don't use an agent) rather than using the online service.  This web page seems to confirm that:  https://www.immigration.go.th/en?page_id=1666 ("The first application for extension of stay by the foreigner is equivalent to the notification of staying in the Kingdom over 90 days", that being the application for the retirement extension itself) although I'll confirm it with Maneerat within the 15 day window.  I plan to let them do the first 15 day report.

This has nothing to do with 90 day reports!
 

Edited by InCider
Posted
On 11/7/2026 at 10:03 AM, Bruce Mangosteen said:

Edit:  Based on rereading the rest of your post, I think you meant the yearly renewal of the retirement extension, rather than the first 90 day report?  In that case, it would confirm my suspicion that doing the transfers ain't worth the hassle, especially for the first renewal.

You're mixing up 90 day 'Notification of stay' reports (totally irrelevant to this discussion) and 90 day Non-O visas. 

The normal route to a 'retirement visa' is to get a Non-O visa and then convert it to an annual extension based on retirement. The Non-O is good for 90 days so you have 90 days to get your 'ducks in a row' and meet the financial requirements. Yes, you can circumvent the financial requirements using an agent - but you're question is specifically about using the INCOME METHOD. I am pointing out, you won't be able RENEW your extension using the income method and pointing out why it will be a problem. 

 

  • Upvote 2
Posted
On 11/7/2026 at 3:23 AM, InCider said:

but there does seem to be some inconsistency in the way different IO's apply the rules. 

And therein lies the problem and the risk with Annual Extensions that deviate from the 800K method.  You can be as scrupulous as you like, but if your IO on the day is one of : grumpy/pissed off with life/didn't  get any last night/hungry/hates farangs/doesn't know the rules/doesn't care about the rules/a born idiot; then you are screwed. 

  • Upvote 1
Posted

I sorted out the problem which was my bank blocking the payment in case it was fraudulent even though i'd entered the code they sent me...duh!!! So I am.waiting for them to process it.

After some more checking I'll definitely just deposit the 800,000.  Using a dodgy IA, who lends you the money just long enough to verify  is asking for trouble.  Immigration are starting to see passbooks and bank statements. 800,000 must be there for 2 months...then cannot drop below 400,000 for even a single day...must be up to 800,000 at least 2 months prior to renewal. i doubt a dodgy IA can cover that.

Also once you are involved you are vulnerable to blackmail from your IA,  and he's a dodgy bastard.

 

Posted
12 hours ago, awesum4 said:

I sorted out the problem which was my bank blocking the payment in case it was fraudulent even though i'd entered the code they sent me...duh!!! So I am.waiting for them to process it.

After some more checking I'll definitely just deposit the 800,000.  Using a dodgy IA, who lends you the money just long enough to verify  is asking for trouble.  Immigration are starting to see passbooks and bank statements. 800,000 must be there for 2 months...then cannot drop below 400,000 for even a single day...must be up to 800,000 at least 2 months prior to renewal. i doubt a dodgy IA can cover that.

Also once you are involved you are vulnerable to blackmail from your IA,  and he's a dodgy bastard.

 

800k needs to be there for 2 months before and 3 months after the renewal date, and balance not drop below 400k for the remaining 7 months. Someone just got their marching orders from Hua Hin and I suspect he failed on this account. 

Posted
17 hours ago, awesum4 said:

Immigration are starting to see passbooks and bank statements.

From agents?  I doubt it mate.  That news would flash though expat circles like a nuclear explosion.

If anything, given how hard they're making it for individual foreigners to open a bank account and provide the correct financial documentation, it almost seems like they're pushing for everyone to use agents.  A poster on another board recently reported that he switched from doing his own yearly renewal to using an agent because of this.

17 hours ago, awesum4 said:

Also once you are involved you are vulnerable to blackmail from your IA,  and he's a dodgy bastard.

And lose all their customers when it got around?  Seems a bad cost/benefit calculation to me. 

Also, how might they do that without incriminating themselves?  Wouldn't they also expose the Immigration Agent they were paying to possible problems? 

Isn't this a bit like a drug dealer threatening to turn a customer in to the cops?

I don't think this is how corruption works.  Everyone involved has to have skin in the game for corruption to work correctly and be sustainable (to use a fancy modern buzzword).

All that said, everybody makes this call for themselves. The only truly wrong answer IMO is when it goes tits up, either because of official crackdowns, or due to the banks deciding they DGAF if your money disappears from your account, or it gets frozen or closed.

  • Upvote 1
Posted

i'm just relaying information that i have heard. As Jacko said people are being deported because they have not followed the rules with regards to money in the bank, or by working when they are on a retirement visa.

I am happy to leave the 800,000 in the bank.  Any bank that would sieze that would quickly lose all its customers when word got around. The difference i would earn on it invested in NZ instead of Thailand would mostly disappear in the thousands extra paid to the dodgy agent. 

  • Upvote 1
Posted (edited)
5 hours ago, awesum4 said:

Any bank that would sieze that would quickly lose all its customers when word got around.

Certainly the risk/ reward calculation is every individual's to choose for himself.  However, I personally know someone who had money disappear from his account,  and there have been news reports on it happening, including to Thais (thought I posted a link to one).  It's also very well known that there have been several waves of farang bank accounts summarily locked and closed. So it HAS gotten around, but it's not like you can avoid the Thai banking system if you want a visa.

OTOH, the agents are still going strong,  and if anything there are many more of them now than there ever were.  I have to believe that the (corrupt) monetary value they generate alone would make that hard to change.

Swings and roundabouts mate.  Ya pays ya money,  and takes ya chances.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

Edited by Bruce Mangosteen
Posted (edited)
On 11/11/2026 at 11:29 AM, Pine Tree said:

And therein lies the problem and the risk with Annual Extensions that deviate from the 800K method.  You can be as scrupulous as you like, but if your IO on the day is one of : grumpy/pissed off with life/didn't  get any last night/hungry/hates farangs/doesn't know the rules/doesn't care about the rules/a born idiot; then you are screwed. 

Agreed. Nearly all the IO's i have dealt with in Bangkok have been old battleaxe's who fall into one or more of those categories 

 

Edited by InCider
.
Posted

I've been retirement extended many times, always without an agent.  The IOs can use their discretion, it's a chance.  If want to impress, wear a tie. I did that once (at Chaengwattana). Lol

Prefer to avoid the 'dodgy' route due to concerns about sustainability, costs 1900 baht per year.

  • Like 2

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...